The CoverGirl of the Week was a title given by the viewers to their favorite model. The viewers are allowed to vote on the CoverGirl website to decide it since cycle 3. The award has been given for every episode except the recap and finale for each cycle. In only cycles 3, 9 and 10, there was one was given on episode 2.
6 titles: Eva Marcille (Cycle 3)
1 title: Lisa D'Amato (Cycle 5), Kim Stolz (Cycle 5), Whitney Cunningham (Cycle 8), Jael Strauss (Cycle 8), Lisa Jackson (Cycle 9), Lauren Utter (Cycle 10), Anya Rozova (Cycle 10) and Whitney Thompson (Cycle 10)
- Eva Marcille was the first ever CoverGirl of the Week.
- Toccara Jones, AJ Stewart, Heather Kuzmich and Katarzyna Dolinska are the only ones to have received the award the week they were eliminated.
- Naima Mora won the title from start to finish.
- Only Heather Kuzmich won the title after she had been eliminated.
- Only Naima Mora, Joanie Dodds, Caridee English, Jaslene Gonzalez and Natasha Galkina have won the award while being called first and only Natasha Galkina managed to get a first call-out, a title and a challenge win in the same week.
- Nicole Linkletter and Saleisha Stowers are the only winners who have never gotten the award.